Welcome to East Of Chicago Pizza Company
East Of Chicago Pizza Company, located at 111 Pike St in Marietta, OH, offers an authentic taste of Chicago-style pizza. Known for its thick and crispy crust, the pizza features generous layers of robust tomato sauce and cheese, providing a satisfying experience for pizza lovers. Customers rave about the impressive buffet, featuring varied pizzas and a well-stocked salad bar, all at an unbeatable price. The friendly atmosphere complements the delicious food, making it a top choice for casual dining. With highlights like the All Meat pizza and taco variety, East Of Chicago promises a delightful meal that keeps patrons coming back.
East Of Chicago Pizza Company: Reviews & Ratings
I ordered the Authentic Chicago Style pizza. Thick crispy crust but bready enough you can cut it with a fork. Robust layers of tomato sauce and cheese. Sometimes I couldn't find the toppings in all of the sauce, and I would have liked to have tasted the toppings more. Still a great pizza for the price.
I’ve eaten here many times before, but it’s been a while. I was able to return yesterday evening with a friend to have dinner. Although this is a bit smaller than other pizza buffets I’ve been to, it’s by far the best! Food, atmosphere and staff are fantastic!
Food was good ,service was great salad bar well stocked. Italian sandwich pizza was my favorite item.
Very good Chicago pizza. We got the All Meat, garlic bread and an Italian sub. The cheesy garlic bread was really good and the sub was delicious, the bread was a little thicker than I like but it was still very good. Nice and clean restaurant and great service. They also have an All You Can eat buffet for only 9.99!
They have the best crust. Their taco pizza is so delicious! They have a pizza buffet that is so good! It's worth the stop. Any pizza is good. Their buffet is awesome!
Very friendly and courteous staff. Chicago style pizza was excellent. We had carry out order but we did check out the Buffet Bar and it was awesome, very well stocked with plenty of options. I know the next visit I will be getting the Buffet.
Absolutely a great dinner buffet. Love the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza. The thin crust Pepperoni & Cheese so good. Nice mixture of pizza on the bar. Ham pineapple and jalapeno pepper. Mushroom pepperoni and banana peppers. Taco Pizza. Desert pizza apple crumble.. Nice Salad bar as well.
Great tasting pizza at a great price. My family got the buffet, and there was a good selection. Pan pizza, thin crust, dessert pizza, salad bar. My son liked the BBQ chicken and pineapple pizza, and I really liked the chicken bacon ranch pizza.
Location
-
111 Pike St, Marietta, OH 45750, United States Hotline: +1 740-374-6000
If you're in Marietta, Ohio, and craving a slice of authentic Chicago-style pizza, look no further than East Of Chicago Pizza Company. Nestled at 111 Pike St, this charming pizzeria combines the robust flavors of the Windy City with a welcoming atmosphere and top-notch service. Whether you're after a hearty meal or a casual bite, this eatery promises a delightful experience for both locals and visitors alike.
As I stepped inside, the inviting ambiance immediately caught my attention. The restaurant may be smaller than some of its competitors, but it makes up for the size with its exceptional offerings. Diners rave about the thick, crispy crust that forms the foundation of their pizzas — perfectly bready yet tender enough to be enjoyed with a fork, reminiscent of the best Chicago deep-dish styles.
One highlight worth mentioning is the robust layers of tomato sauce and cheese that characterize their pizzas. Although some customers have noted the toppings occasionally play hide-and-seek under the generous sauce, reviews suggest that the flavor is bold and satisfying. Popular choices like the All Meat and the flavorful taco pizza exemplify the variety the menu offers. The addition of a well-stocked salad bar and a delightful Italian sandwich pizza rounds out the meal options, perfect for sharing or indulging on your own.
But it’s not just about the pizzas. Regular patrons sing praises for the all-you-can-eat buffet at an unbeatable price of $9.99. It's a testament to the value you receive that keeps customers returning. Culinary delights like the cheesy garlic bread have also garnered acclaim, adding a satisfying side to any meal.
The service at East Of Chicago Pizza Company is consistently highlighted as exemplary. With friendly staff who ensure a fulfilling dining experience, you'll likely feel like family by the time you leave. As Priscilla Milam noted, returning to this quaint pizzeria after some time felt like a warm homecoming.
Food critics and casual diners alike will find something to love at East Of Chicago Pizza Company. It is not just about filling your stomach; it’s about sharing good food, good company, and creating unforgettable memories — one slice at a time.